Home > Knitting & Crochet > Joint & Thumb Pain

4 Reasons Your Thumb Pain Keeps Coming Back When You Knit and Crochet

Diane Whitfield

Last Updated September 1st, 2026

Read on to find the likely culprits behind your thumb pain, and what finally let me keep knitting.

1. The Splints, Gloves and Creams You Have Already Tried Were Never Designed For Knitters

It is not that nothing works. It is that nothing you tried was made for knitters.

Compression gloves. A rigid thumb splint your doctor swore by. CBD rub. Maybe a brace off Amazon that broke at the seam in a week, or cortisone shots that bought you six weeks the first time.

I had bought so many different braces over the years, all of them designed for someone resting an injured hand. Every one built by a person who has never picked up a needle. Not one of them let me actually knit while I wore it.

2. The Real Problem Is the Joint at the Base of Your Thumb

It is one joint: the CMC, at the base of your thumb, sitting on a small bone called the trapezium. Years of gripping the needle have worn it loose. Now every stitch shifts it past itself. One shift you would never feel. But it is a thousand an hour. And as long as it keeps sliding, the pain has nowhere to settle.

That is why it flares twenty minutes in and eases the moment you set the needles down. Age does not come and go with the stitching. A loose joint does.

3. The Swelling Is What Keeps Bringing the Pain Back

Once the joint starts shifting, your body swells the tissue around it to protect it. But that swelling is what stiffens the joint. So the next stitch hurts more. More pain, more swelling.

That is why resting does not break it. Put the needles down for a week, even two, and the pain settles. Pick them back up, and within an hour it is back. Usually worse than before.

This is the part almost every brace ignores. Support alone holds the joint still. It does nothing about the swelling that keeps feeding the ache.

4. Every Solution Doctors Offer You Makes Knitting Harder, Not Easier

This is the part that makes most of us furious.

A cortisone shot buys a few months, then less, then the talk turns to surgery.

Try Continental asks you to relearn how you hold the yarn after 50, 60, sometimes 70 years.

Just stop knitting takes away the one thing that keeps your hands and your head working. This is not a hobby. It is our lifeline. I would be lost without it.

So What Can You Actually Do About It?

There is only one way to get lasting relief: support the joint that is actually sliding, the CMC at the base of your thumb, and calm the swelling it causes at the same time.

That is harder than it sounds. The brace has to do five things at once:

✓ Support the one joint every glove and splint leaves moving

✓ Do it without locking the thumb, so you can still work a stitch

✓ Treat the swelling while you knit, not hours later with an ice pack

✓ Stay comfortable enough to wear the whole time, not for twenty minutes at a stretch

✓ Use cold therapy to calm swelling, and heat therapy to improve blood flow and reduce stiffness

So a hand therapist who works with knitters and crocheters set out to build one.

The First Brace Built Around the Way a Knitter's Thumb Actually Moves

They called it the Resilea Thermacompress Knitting Wrist Brace, and it is the first one made around how a knitter's thumb actually works:

A contoured pad supports the CMC joint at the base of your thumb, the exact joint every other brace leaves moving

A slim gel insert goes cold for a flare or warm for morning stiffness, so the swelling gets handled while you knit instead of hours later

All four fingers and both fingertips stay bare, so you grip and tension the yarn exactly as you always have

Soft, light and slim enough to settle in and work for hours, not twenty minutes at a stretch

CHECK AVAILABILITY

I left the link above if you want to have a look.

If your hands are anything like mine were, it is worth a look.

Diane

Most relevant

17 comments

Olivia Wilson

Can anybody vouch for these?

3 likes

Like Reply 1d

Christina Boyd

I have been knitting for over 30 years and the last two years my thumbs got worse and worse. I had to stop after 20 minutes because the ache at the base of my thumb was unbearable. I freeze the insert before my evening session, slide it on, and I can comfortably knit for over an hour. My fingers stay completely free to work the needles and the cold does not drip on my yarn, which was my biggest worry.

9 likes

Like Reply 1d

Annie Jones

Crocheting is my lifeline. Yes, arthritic pain. Knitting for 61 years and crocheting for 33 years and I am not stopping now.

3 likes

Like Reply 3d

Crystal Jones

I have been a quilter for over 50 years and I have had two thumb surgeries. These do not get in the way of my quilting at all and they give me the support I need. The cooling also takes away that burning feeling in my thumb. So relieving.

12 likes

Like Reply 3d

Dawn Taylor

Thank you for putting this up. I am still recovering from a trigger finger operation after two successful ones in the past. You have inspired me to be proactive and book an appointment at a hand clinic, so hopefully this eases my problem too.

3 likes

Like Reply 1w

Shirley Baker

I am 71 and in the last two years I had both thumb joints replaced. My physio told me the best exercise was knitting, and it has helped me get the movement back in my hands.

8 likes

Like Reply 2w

Margaret Summers

Has anyone actually tried this? My thumbs have been getting worse for years and my doctor just keeps offering me cortisone shots. I am 64 and frankly terrified of surgery.

3 likes

Like Reply 2w

Mary Woodford

Margaret, I use one on each hand for knitting and cross stitching. Keeping the thumb joints supported and warm means I can enjoy my crafts for longer. I only take them off at night or when my hands get wet.

6 likes

Like Reply 2w

Pauline Smith

Ok but is it actually different from the 30 dollar ones on Amazon? I have bought about five of those over the years and every single one broke at the seam within a week.

4 likes

Like Reply 3w

Janet Bailey

Pauline, I had the exact same thought. The cheap ones either fall apart or they are so bulky you cannot knit while wearing them. This one is slim enough that you can still hold the needles properly. Three months of daily wear and nothing has gone slack.

6 likes

Like Reply 2w

Jennifer Bale

It does not say whether it is for the left or right hand. I need it for my right.

Like Reply 3w

Julie McGrann

Jennifer, it fits either wrist. I found the details in the product information section.

Like Reply 3w

Avery Jackson

Does anyone know how long the shipping takes? Want to buy some for the girls at knit and natter.

1 like

Like Reply 4w

Jeniffer Hurley

Avery, mine arrived after about a week. I had carpal tunnel surgery and needed something portable, I was using a bag of frozen peas in a tea towel before this. Ice cold, form fitting and soft. I bought two so I can alternate.

5 likes

Like Reply 4w